The introduction of the book “As-Sahifat-us-Sajjadiyyah”
Question:
What is written in the introduction of the book “As-Sahifat-us-Sajjadiyyah” (the Leaves of Prostration) which was omitted from the translation and was replaced although it belongs to the book and contains its chain to Imam As-Sajjad (a.)?
Answer:
Continue reading
Abu Musa confirms the cowardice of Umar
Question:
Is Abu Musa Al-Hanafi, who reports the cowardice of Umar, unknown (majhul) according to Ibn Hajar Al-Asqalani?
Answer:
Continue reading
Does Aban lie according to Al-Amini?
Question:
Did Al-Amini classify the narrator Aban Ibn Abi Ayyash as a liar?
Answer:
Continue reading
Al-Kashani on the contradictions with regard to classifications
Question:
Can we rely on the classification of the chains of transmission according to Al-Kashani
Answer:
Continue reading
Al-Hurr Al-Amili on the weakening by At-Tusi
Muhammad Al-Hurr Al-Amili writes:
Continue reading
Weak does not mean unauthentic for At-Tusi as it does today
Muhammad Ibn Hasan At-Tusi writes:
Continue reading
Bahrani rejects classifications
Question:
Did Yusuf Al-Bahrani reject the classification of chains of transmission?
Answer:
Continue reading
Reject weak reports?
Question:
Do all scholars agree that one should not follow traditions whose chains have been classified as weak (Da’if)?
Answer:
Continue reading
Al-Ghada’iri about Kitab Sulaim
Question:
Did Ibn Al-Ghada’iri classify the reports of Kitab Sulaim as weak?
Answer:
Continue reading
Al-Mufid about Kitab Sulaim
Question:
What was the opinion of the scholar Al-Mufid about the work “Kitab Sulaim”?
Answer:
Continue reading